The Crisis of Aging Inmates
Many elderly inmates are now in their 60’s, 70’s and 80’s. The release of these inmates, many who were imprisoned for non-violent crimes and/or drug possession would not constitute a danger to their communities. A fiscal analysis by the ACLU found that states would save approximately $66,000 a year for each elderly inmate released from prison.
Bruce Harrison, a 63 year old federal inmate, has served almost twenty one years of a fifty year sentence.
Mr. Harrison was arrested in 1994 with other members of his motorcycle group for transporting large amounts of marijuana and cocaine. The arrests were part of a sting by undercover federal agents. Mr. Harrison was paid $1,000 for each trip ( several trips) and received a fifty year sentence. After the sentences were imposed, jurors objected to the mandatory sentence in light of the extenuating circumstances. Today, revised federal sentencing guidelines impose much lower prison terms for low-level drug offenders.
Unfortunately, Mr. Harrison, a highly decorated Vietnam War veteran, is still incarcerated. He walks with special medical boots because of a painful foot condition that causes him to feel he’s “stepping on a needle.’ He has suffered from vertigo and is undergoing tests for a heart condition.
The American Civil Liberties Union issued a report in 2013 about elderly inmates. The elderly inmate population has increased 1300 percent since the early 1980’s. The federal government and the states spend more than $16 billion a year to incarcerate aging inmates. The report noted that almost all inmates over 50 are not a threat to society. It costs $68,000 to imprison an elderly inmate which was twice the cost to imprison a young inmate. The difference in costs resulted from health care expenses which increased every year.
Health care in prisons is inadequate at best and at the worst– horrible for the elderly. The physicians and their assistants are not trained for care of the geriatric prison population. Most prisons do not treat elderly inmates differently from young inmates although their healthcare requirements are so different. On a personal note, I watched inmates stand in line outside in the rain for 30 minutes waiting for their medications. Some of these inmates were over 70 and required canes to walk.
Elderly inmates are easily victimized by predatory inmates. I knew one inmate in his 50’s who was attacked by a 21 year old inmate because the young man wanted his chair. Some prisons do have tiers for inmates who are over the age of 40. This policy has helped somewhat in protecting older inmates from younger inmates, but has not eliminated this problem, since all inmates share the chow hall and the outside areas.
According to Jamie Fellner, a senior advisor at Human Rights Watch and an author of a report, “Old Behind Bars,” “There are countless ways that the aging inmates, some with dementia, bump up against the prison culture,”… the prison culture,”… “It is difficult to climb to the upper bunk, walk up stairs, wait outside for pills, take showers in facilities without bars and even hear the commands to stand up for count or sit down when you’re told.”
There are solutions for this growing crisis. First, we need to eliminate all mandatory sentencing and allow the judges sentencing discretion. Second, our justice system should look to alternative sentencing programs instead of prison for defendants who have committed nonviolent crimes. Third, the decisions regarding parole and early compassionate release should place more emphasis on the age and health of the inmate. Fourth, we need to have prisons dedicated to only elderly inmates.
How we treat our elderly inmates certainly defines our society.
By: Bradley Schwartz
Founder of prisonpath.com
——————– Hi Bradley, As alway’s a very good article, on G+ I already have had a comment about youre article. My question is 1) who is going to pay all the costs for those eldery nonviolent inmates? I ask because you cannot expect these people to start to work and these people will not have any savings. 2) Why cannot the violent people get out of prisons and into nursery homes or where eldery people live in the US? I mean these people will not be that violent anymore and if the are still violent then it will be probaly… Read more »
Boke, All good questions. In terms of elderly nonviolent inmates, many still have family for support. Keep in mind that a substantial number could live with family and have healthcare via medicare. Since they are nonviolent, they are not a danger to the community. For those who require in house care, they would receive care in nursing homes and medicare would cover the costs. Yes, medicare is federally funded, but overall there would be an economic savings in terms of reduced prisons, etc. It would also mean a more humane resolution of this crisis. In terms of violent elderly inmates,… Read more »
With all the ill inmates is there anyway to have probiotics mailed to them to help with low immune systems? Wouldn’t this help lower medical treatments. Is there a company that they can order from through jPay?